UofG Centre for Public Policy

12 November 2026: The recent budget introduced a new Preventative Departmental Expenditure Limit (PDEL) that will ringfence spending that reduces future costs. Dr Ian C. Elliott writes that lasting progress will also require stronger institutions to scrutinise and sustain future-focused policymaking.

Blog by Dr Ian C. Elliott

Much of the analysis of the recent budget has described it as a low-key, underwhelming or a safe hands budget. Indeed, IPSOS have noted considerably less online discussion related to the budget than the previous two years. Yet this budget contained a potentially transformational change in the development of a new Preventative Departmental Expenditure Limit (PDEL) that will ringfence spending that reduces future costs. 

Nick Davies from the Institute for Government was quick to celebrate this as a ‘huge win’ and later the Institute for Government described this as ‘hugely welcome’, while The Guardian described it as “welcome and potentially consequential” and a "world-first focus on long-term outcomes".  

But having a relatively small pot of funding ringfenced for preventative programmes is unlikely to be transformational by itself. A particular challenge is that there is no agreed definition of what counts as preventative spending. Consequently, there is a risk that existing expenditure is simply relabelled as preventative. And with rising fiscal pressure there will always be a temptation to cut any long-term investment in favour of immediate spending priorities. Ultimately, budget mechanisms can be created quickly, but they can be dismantled just as quickly. 

This challenge sits at the heart of my recent work on the strategic state. I argue that the strategic state is "a whole-of-government approach to the design and delivery of public services which links a shared long-term vision with the collective capacity, capability and conviction to make it happen"[1]. It has been suggested that the recent budget has begun to put the strategic state into practice. But, strategic capacity requires institutions that can maintain attention on long-term goals despite electoral cycles, political turnover and recurring crises.  

PDEL is a step in the right direction, but it remains unclear how the UK Government will be scrutinised and held to account for preventative policy. That is why the case for a Parliamentary Committee for the Future deserves renewed attention. Such a committee could provide systematic scrutiny of the long-term implications of legislation, spending decisions and major policy reforms. International experience, such as Finland’s Committee for the Future which has operated since 1993, suggests this model can work by embedding futures thinking within parliamentary scrutiny.  

A Parliamentary Committee for the Future could strengthen the UK Parliament’s capacity to assess whether governments are building and sustaining strategic capability. It could examine progress against long-term national outcomes, assess the intergenerational implications of public spending decisions, and provide a focal point for scrutiny of preventative investment. In doing so, it would create a durable parliamentary demand for evidence of long-term thinking. 

 Sustaining a long-term outcomes-based approach to government requires continuous institutional reinforcement. A long-term vision and strategic ambitions are not enough. Without enduring mechanisms of accountability and scrutiny, long-term goals risk becoming disconnected from everyday decisions about spending and implementation. 

The introduction of PDEL offers an important opportunity to shift resources towards prevention. But if prevention is to become a durable feature of governance rather than a temporary budgeting experiment, the UK also needs institutions capable of defending long-term priorities. A Parliamentary Committee for the Future would not guarantee strategic government. It would, however, strengthen one of the foundations on which any strategic state depends: the capacity to maintain democratic attention on the future. 

Author

Dr Ian C. Elliott is a Senior Lecturer in Public Administration at the Centre for Public Policy. His research includes the strategic state and mission-led government as well as the teaching of public administration. Ian has extensive experience of advising governments and conducting research on behalf of governments and public bodies including most recently as a member of Scottish Government Reform Advisory Group for the National Performance Framework.

[1] Elliott, I. C. (2023). "Chapter 6: The strategic state: a case study of devolved government in Scotland". In Handbook on Strategic Public Management. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing. 


First published: 13 November 2026