UofG Centre for Public Policy

23 October 2026: Discussions on regional governance are in the spotlight in Scotland, alongside Andy Burnham's recent speech in Motherwell, and renewed interest in regional policy from both the UK and Scottish Governments. Dr David Waite, Professor Graeme Roy, and Professor Stuart McIntyre examine key points of the PM's speech and ways regional working could be meaningfully progressed.

Blog by Dr David Waite, Professor Graeme Roy, and Professor Stuart McIntyre

Regional governance discussions are taking place across Scotland. This is informed by evolving Scottish Government positions, and, somewhat strikingly, a recent tilt toward local government reform. A regionalist agenda is also prompted by the UK Government’s reinvigorated interest in regional policy UK-wide (indeed, the July 31 Cabinet paper reaffirmed this) where claims for 'Manchesterism' loom large.

Contributing to this, a notable intervention was made by the Prime Minister Andy Burnham in Motherwell on Friday (October 16). The timing of Burnham’s speech has captured significant attention, as, for one thing, it coincided with the SNP conference.

In terms of content, Burnham’s speech noted an explicit provision concerning DWP working (“a model of localised employment support”). Otherwise, the speech devoted attention to collaborative working with the Scottish Government more generally. The Prime Minister noted to this effect: “I do want good growth in every postcode here and the rest of the UK…and I want to work with the First Minister to deliver it”.

More specifically, some key points in the speech concerning next steps for Scottish city-regional and regional policymaking align with what we have been calling for over the last 12 months (here and here):

  1. Working effectively across tripartite governance (i.e. the UK, Scottish and local governments working together effectively);
  2. Not bluntly importing the English model (Burnham appeared to have moved away from the strict necessity of introducing mayors, for example);
  3. Considering the varied economic bases and trajectories across Scotland's city-regions and regions.

In short, there is an opportunity now with both the UK Government and the Scottish Government pointing in the same direction. Indeed, if a joint agreement to constructively work with local bodies and Regional Economic Partnerships to advance city-regional and regional policy can be realised, effective regional policy actions may result. Productive links to the UK industrial strategy may be forged here as well.

Regional working could be usefully progressed in several ways.

At a local level, there is a need to be clear on the powers and responsibilities being asked for and why. Rather than simply listing desired powers, lobbying for more funding, or rushing to adopt a system in effect elsewhere (e.g. a mayoral one), we think there is merit in, first, clarifying the challenges and issues confronting our regional economies, before, second, considering where the levers are held and who does (and should do) what. To advance the first step here, we have argued that a medium/long-term view expressed through a local growth plan presents clear benefits.

Scottish Government and UK Government could provide a useful joint push for a common framework on decentralisation (akin to the English devolution white paper) at the same time as local growth plans are being pursued. This could start by clearly laying out what the existing complementarities are across SG and UKG.

Mapping SG’s public service reform steps, the Programme for Government and the green industrial strategy, with the UKG’s devolution statements along with the UK industrial strategy, would be a good starting point. The aim - with a framework agreed - would be to set out what is on the table in terms of empowerment, and what assurances and accountability steps local and regional actors need to provide.

Finally, it is not just the Scottish Government that has to think about the new regionalism agenda of the Burnham government and how it may be configured within a devolved administration. The Welsh Government faces a similar challenge. Though powers and responsibilities at Cardiff Bay and Holyrood differ, negotiating the tripartite framework of regional politics provides a set of common principles to build a constructive dialogue around. It is notable too, that the Welsh First Minister recently opened up a conversation on regional working within Wales (coined as a “partnership for growth”).

Regional economic development - as we have written before - has been unstructured, somewhat random and piecemeal. Too often it has been about funding allocations, who does what, and who claims credit. The alignment of the agendas of the Scottish and UK Governments provides an opportunity to address this. This will require linking the two agendas, drawing out practical ideas with regional and local bodies on what they need for growth, and then taking action.

Authors

Dr David Waite - david.waite@glasgow.ac.uk - is a Senior Lecturer in the University of Glasgow's School of Social and Political Sciences. David's research focuses on the development of second-tier city-regions, with interest in the underpinning production systems at and the governance responses for these places. He is a Senior Fellow of the University of Glasgow Centre for Public Policy.

Graeme Roy is Professor of Economics, Deputy Head of the College of Social Sciences and Assistant Vice Principal at the University of Glasgow. Graeme is Chair of the Scottish Fiscal Commission, Scotland’s official independent economic and fiscal forecaster. He is a Senior Fellow of the University of Glasgow Centre for Public Policy.

Stuart McIntyre is a Professor of Economics at the University of Strathclyde. He is a Fellow of the Office for National Statistics and a Research Associate at the ONS-funded Economic Statistics Centre of Excellence.


First published: 23 October 2026