Lewis Chessmen, Isle of Lewis
Re-assessing the Lewis Hoard of gaming pieces
Mark A Hall (Perth Museum & Art Gallery) and David H Caldwell (formerly National Museums Scotland)
c. AD 1150-1250
Between 2007 and 2018 Mark A Hall and David H Caldwell carried out a re-assessment of the Lewis hoard of gaming pieces, popularly known as the Lewis chessmen. We sought to move the debate onto new ground in several areas: 1. The island context was re-assessed in terms of the hoard being there deliberately rather than as a mere accident of the weather; this permitted a Kingdom of the Isles context to be established. This context also linked to debates about cultural identity and the Norse-Gael transition. 2. The gaming context was re-assessed to broaden out from chess to assess the other board-games represented: merels, tables and hnefatafl, and in particular the fluidity between chess and hnefatafl. The wider cultural significance of board-games was also assessed. 3. Working with Dr. Caroline Wilkinson (then Dundee, now Liverpool [John Moore’s] University), facial anthropology was carried out on the faces of the figurative pieces to establish sets of traits that indicated the work of at least 4 workshops. Trondheim was confirmed as the most likely place of manufacture. 4. The legacy effect of the chess pieces was considered in contemporary, modern popular culture.
The research delivered outputs in terms of exhibitions and displays across Scotland, international conferences, a range of publications and media coverage.
Lewis chessmen, Isle of Lewis, gaming, gaming pieces, chess, hnefatafl, walrus ivory
Caldwell, D H and Hall, M A 2018 ‘The Hoard of Gaming Pieces from Lewis, Scotland: Context and meaning’, in Stempin, A. (ed.) The Cultural Role of Chess in Medieval and Modern Times, 50th Anniversary Jubilee of the Sandomierz Chess Discovery, Poznań, (= Bibliotheca Fontes Archaeologici Posnanienses 21), 97-108.
Hall, M A 2017 ‘Gaming, Material Culture and Hybridity: The Kingdom of the Isles at play’, in Cooijmans, C. (ed.) Traversing the Inner Seas Contacts and Continuity in and around Scotland, the Hebrides and the North of Ireland, Edinburgh: The Scottish Society for Northern Studies, 51-84.
Hall, M A 2014 ‘Board of the Kings: The material culture of playtime in Scotland AD 1-1600’, in Teichert, M (ed.) Sport und Spiel bei den Germanen, Nordeuropa von der römischen Kaiserzeit bis zum Mittelalter, Berlin & Boston: De Gruyter (= Ergänzungsbände zum Reallexikon der germanischen Altertumskunde Band 88), 163-196.
Caldwell, D H and Hall, M A (eds) 2014 The Lewis Chessmen: New Perspectives, Edinburgh: NMS Publishing/SAS.
Caldwell, D H, Hall, M A & Wilkinson, C M 2010 The Lewis Chessmen Unmasked, Edinburgh: NMS Publishing.
Caldwell, D H, Hall, M A & Wilkinson, C M 2010 ‘The Lewis chessmen: New ideas’, in History Scotland Jan/Feb 2010, 4-6.
Caldwell, D H, Hall, M A & Wilkinson, C M 2009 ‘The Lewis hoard of gaming pieces: A re-examination of their context, meanings, discovery and manufacture’, in Medieval Archaeology 53, 155-203.